Where to Buy Ricotta Cheese
You can buy ricotta cheese at most supermarkets, Italian grocery stores, specialty cheese shops, and online grocery or creamery stores. A refrigerated supermarket tub is usually the easiest option for everyday cooking; an Italian market or creamery is a better place to look for freshly made or specifically whey-based ricotta. Here’s how to find a seller, choose the right product, and check the package before buying.
Where Ricotta Is in the Grocery Store
Start in the refrigerated dairy section, near the cottage cheese, sour cream, or cream cheese. Ricotta usually comes in a plastic tub rather than a block or bag of shredded cheese.
If it isn’t there, check the deli’s refrigerated specialty-cheese case, especially near fresh mozzarella and mascarpone. Stores may keep everyday ricotta in the dairy aisle and specialty versions at the cheese counter.
For most recipes that simply call for “ricotta,” you want soft, spoonable fresh ricotta. Ricotta salata is a different product: it is salted, aged, and firm enough to crumble or grate. It is not a direct replacement for the soft ricotta used in lasagna, stuffed shells, or cheesecake.
How to Find and Buy Ricotta Cheese
Choose a shopping route based on the kind of ricotta you need.
| What You Want | Where to Start | What to Check |
|---|---|---|
| A standard tub for everyday cooking | Supermarket or grocery pickup service | Whole-milk versus part-skim, package size, and local stock |
| Ricotta made in-house or by a nearby producer | Italian grocery, cheese shop, or creamery | Who makes it and whether it is available for pickup |
| A particular brand or specialty product | Brand store locator or retailer search | The exact product, not just the brand name |
| Specifically whey-based ricotta | Creamery or specialty-cheese seller | Product description and ingredients |
| Home delivery | Local grocery delivery or a creamery’s online store | Delivery area, chilled handling, and total checkout cost |
Step 1: Find a Nearby Seller
- Search your usual supermarket’s website with your location selected. Walmart, Target, Kroger-family stores, and Whole Foods Market are reasonable places to check. Search “ricotta cheese,” then select the actual store or delivery address; a national product listing does not establish local availability.
- Call an Italian grocery or cheese shop if the supermarket selection doesn’t fit. Ask whether the ricotta is available today and whether the shop can hold it. This is especially useful when you need a particular texture or enough for a large recipe.
- Use a maker’s locator for a specific product. For The Cheese Guy’s Organic Whole Milk Whipped Fresh Ricotta, use the “STORE LOCATOR: Find a store near you” option on The Cheese Guy product page. Confirm with the retailer that it carries that ricotta, rather than only other cheeses from the brand.
- Verify pickup arrangements before traveling to a creamery. Confirm retail hours, pickup availability, and stock before treating a creamery as a walk-in shopping destination.
Step 2: Search for the Right Product
- Match the recipe’s wording when it specifies a type of ricotta. Search for the type of ricotta you need.
- Use an exact product search when whey-based ricotta matters. Caputo Brothers Creamery sells Fresh Ricotta (whey-based), made by reheating whey from its cheesemaking without vinegar or citric acid. That gives you a named option rather than relying on “Italian-style” packaging to identify how a cheese was made.
- Read the ingredients and allergen statement. The Cheese Guy’s Organic Whole Milk Whipped Fresh Ricotta lists organic whole milk, organic vinegar, and salt, with the allergen declaration “Contains Milk.” Confirm ingredients and allergen information on the package you are buying, since formulations and products differ.
Whey-based and milk-based ricotta can both work in home cooking. If your recipe does not specify the production method, texture and moisture are often more useful shopping criteria than whether the cheese began with milk or whey.
Step 3: Check Quantity and Price Before Checkout
- Buy by the amount your recipe requires, not by an assumed tub size. Packages vary. Caputo Brothers Creamery’s Fresh Ricotta (whey-based), for example, comes in baskets of 1–1.25 pounds; confirm the weight on the listing or basket label when deciding how much to order.
- Compare the exact products and package weights. Organic Whole Milk Whipped Fresh Ricotta is $9.00, while Fresh Ricotta (whey-based) is $11.00. These are product-specific listed prices. Confirm the current price on the maker’s product page or seller’s listing before checkout, and use price per ounce when the package weights are available.
- Include delivery costs in the comparison. A specialty cheese ordered directly from a creamery may have shipping or chilled-packaging charges. Check that the seller delivers to your address and that the total cost still makes sense for the quantity you need.
Step 4: Inspect the Package and Check for Recalls
- Choose a properly chilled package with an intact seal. Check the printed date and avoid leaking or damaged containers. For cheese packed at a counter, make sure you receive enough product information to identify the maker.
- Screen for the Clover Hill Dairy recall. In its June 3, 2026 advisory, the Maryland Department of Health identified recalled Clover Hill Dairy requesón/soft ricotta products by the manufacturer permit or plant number 24-128. Check that identifier on the package, not only the brand on the front. The recalled products were sold through the dairy’s retail market, farmers markets, and third-party distributors, including in New York and Virginia. Some were flavored, including jalapeño varieties, and distributed products could carry a different brand name. Those states are not an exhaustive distribution list.
- Do not buy or eat a recalled product. Maryland’s advisory directs consumers to dispose of products containing the affected Clover Hill Dairy requesón/soft ricotta. If you already have affected cheese, discard it and clean the refrigerator, containers, and surfaces that may have touched it, as directed by the CDC.
This recall concerns identified products, not every brand of ricotta.
Step 5: Take It Home and Refrigerate It
- Keep ricotta chilled during transport. Use an insulated bag with a cold pack, then refrigerate it promptly at 40°F or below. For delivery, arrange to receive the order and put the cheese away on arrival.
- Keep the package information with the cheese. Retain the maker’s name, date, and any after-opening storage instructions. Once opened, keep the container covered and note the opening date so it is easier to manage what needs using.
Choosing Ricotta for Your Recipe
The right ricotta is the one whose texture fits the dish, not necessarily the most expensive tub.
Lasagna and Stuffed Pasta
Use the whole-milk or part-skim style your recipe requests. Whole-milk ricotta generally gives a richer filling, while part-skim versions can be a little firmer or less creamy.
Moisture matters, too. If the recipe calls for drained ricotta, buying a product labeled “fresh” does not eliminate that preparation. A very loose cheese can change the consistency of a filling even when the package weight is correct.
Cannoli, Cheesecake, and Gnocchi
For these dishes, pay close attention to the recipe’s texture requirements. A cannoli filling needs enough body to hold its shape, while excess moisture in ricotta gnocchi can change how much flour the dough needs.
At a cheese counter, name the dish you are making rather than asking only for the “best” ricotta. The seller may be able to distinguish a firmer, drier option from a soft, custard-like one.
Toast, Dips, and Serving Plain
A smooth, creamy ricotta is convenient when you want to spread it or serve it without further preparation. A product labeled “whipped” is worth considering for those uses.
For a recipe that depends on distinct curds or a firm filling, do not assume whipped ricotta will behave like an unwhipped version. The texture description is part of the product choice, not just marketing language.
Confirming Your Ricotta Order
For grocery pickup or delivery, substitution settings can determine whether you receive a useful ingredient. Before submitting the order, check:
- Product type: The selected item is soft ricotta, not ricotta salata or another cheese.
- Recipe requirements: Any permitted substitute matches essential details such as whole-milk, part-skim, or unwhipped.
- Quantity: A replacement package still supplies enough for the recipe.
- Specialty requirements: If you specifically need whey-based ricotta, a generic ricotta substitution may not meet that requirement.
When a particular product is essential, select “no substitutions” or request approval before a replacement. Set those preferences before placing the order.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which Store-Bought Ricotta Cheese Is Best?
There is no single best store-bought ricotta for every dish. Galbani, Polly-O, and BelGioioso are practical brands to compare where stocked, but choose the specific product by texture, ingredients, and your recipe’s requirements rather than brand alone. A smooth ricotta may suit toast beautifully while a firmer one is more convenient for a filling.
Where Can I Purchase Fresh-Made Ricotta in Central Massachusetts?
Italian markets, specialty cheese shops, and local creameries are the best places to ask about fresh-made ricotta in central Massachusetts. Ask whether it is made on-site or supplied by a named producer, when it will be available, and whether you can reserve it for pickup. “Fresh ricotta” describes a cheese style and does not, by itself, mean it was made in that shop that day.
What Are Good Ricotta Brands to Look for in Springfield, PA?
Galbani, Polly-O, and BelGioioso are useful brand searches for Springfield-area supermarket websites, but they are not a guarantee of local stock. For freshly made options, contact nearby Italian delis or cheese shops and ask who produces their ricotta. Caputo Brothers Creamery’s listed location is in Spring Grove, not Springfield, so confirm the destination before planning a trip.
Who Makes Coarse Ricotta?
For a coarser texture, look for unwhipped ricotta with visible curds at an Italian grocery or cheese counter. “Coarse” is not a consistent brand-level description, so ask to see the cheese or request a texture description before buying. Avoid products specifically labeled “whipped” if distinct curds are what you want.
