Traeger Grill Filet Mignon Recipe With Garlic Butter

To cook filet mignon on a Traeger, coat the steaks with garlic butter, grill over high heat with the lid closed, and use a thermometer, not the clock, to decide when they’re ready. This recipe follows Traeger’s straightforward, grate-grilled method rather than a low-temperature smoke and reverse sear. It includes the seasoning amounts, grill settings, and doneness targets.

Why Filet Mignon Needs a Temperature Probe

Filet mignon is a steak cut from the beef tenderloin. It is exceptionally tender but has little intramuscular fat, so it doesn’t have the richness, or the margin for overcooking, of a well-marbled ribeye.

Garlic butter adds flavor to this lean cut without requiring a marinade. High-heat grilling browns the outside, while a center-temperature reading helps you avoid leaving the steak on the grill longer than necessary.

Steak thickness, starting temperature, and grill performance all affect cooking time. Two filets can look equally browned yet have different temperatures inside, which is why each steak needs its own check.

Ingredients and Equipment

These quantities make two servings and follow Traeger’s U.S. filet mignon recipe. If you choose a different Traeger recipe, confirm the quantities in that version’s ingredient list rather than combining its seasoning amounts with another recipe’s instructions.

Ingredients

  • 2 filet mignon steaks
  • 1 teaspoon kosher salt
  • 1 teaspoon freshly ground black pepper
  • 2 cloves garlic, minced
  • 3 tablespoons unsalted butter, softened

Choose filets of similar thickness so they are more likely to finish together. Traeger’s recipe does not specify a steak weight or thickness, so its cooking-time estimate should not be treated as a guarantee for every filet.

Use softened butter, not melted butter. It should be easy to mix and spread over the meat. Mince the garlic finely so it distributes through the coating instead of collecting in large pieces.

Equipment

  • Traeger pellet grill
  • Grill-safe leave-in temperature probe or an instant-read thermometer
  • Tongs
  • Small mixing bowl
  • Paper towels
  • Clean serving plate

A leave-in probe lets you monitor the center without repeatedly opening the lid. An instant-read thermometer is useful for checking the other steak and verifying the reading before serving. Only leave a thermometer in the grill if it is designed for that use.

How to Cook Filet Mignon on a Traeger

Garlic-butter-coated filets grill at 450°F until they reach the chosen center temperature, then rest for at least 3 minutes before serving.

Step 1: Make the Garlic Butter and Season the Steaks

  1. Pat the filets dry with paper towels. Remove surface moisture before adding the butter coating; a wet surface makes browning more difficult.
  2. For Traeger’s U.S. butter rub, combine 1 teaspoon kosher salt, 1 teaspoon freshly ground black pepper, 2 minced garlic cloves, and 3 tablespoons softened unsalted butter in a small bowl.
  3. Rub the mixture over both sides of the filets, distributing it evenly rather than leaving thick clumps.
  4. Let the coated filets rest for 15 minutes before cooking. Traeger’s regional recipes use a 10–15-minute seasoning rest; confirm the exact interval in Step 1 of the applicable Traeger recipe.

This is a scheduled seasoning rest, not a requirement to leave the steaks out until their centers reach room temperature. You can start preheating the grill while the coated filets rest.

Step 2: Preheat the Traeger With the Lid Closed

  1. Use Steak Blend pellets if you want to follow the pellet choice in this recipe.
  2. Set the Traeger to 450°F and preheat with the lid closed for 15 minutes.
  3. Have your tongs, thermometer, and clean serving plate ready before adding the steaks.

The seasoning rest and preheat can overlap, but both should be complete before the filets go onto the grates. Do not shorten preheating simply because the meat is ready; hot grates are important for browning during a relatively brief cook.

Step 3: Choose a Doneness Target and Grill

Choose a center-temperature target for your preferred culinary doneness:

Doneness Center Temperature
Rare 120–130°F
Medium-rare 130–135°F
Medium 135–145°F
Medium-well 145–155°F
Well-done 155–165°F

These are culinary doneness ranges, not interchangeable food-safety endpoints.

  1. Position the probe in the center. Insert it from the side into the thickest part of a filet, with the sensing tip at the center of the meat. A tip sitting close to the surface can read hotter than the center and make the steak appear farther along than it is.
  2. Grill directly on the grates. Place the filets on the grill and close the lid. For Traeger’s 450°F method, expect approximately 5–8 minutes per side, flipping with tongs and closing the lid again afterward.
  3. Check each steak before removing it. For Traeger’s medium-rare endpoint, remove the filets when their centers reach 130–135°F. Overcooking makes this lean, tender cut progressively firmer and drier. For the USDA-recommended finish, continue cooking until the center reaches 145°F before removal.

Begin checking at the shorter end of the cooking-time range. A thick filet may need longer, while a smaller or thinner steak may finish sooner. Remove the steaks separately as they finish.

The temperature can continue rising during the rest, so leaving a steak on the grill after it reaches your target leaves less room for carryover cooking.

Step 4: Rest and Serve

  1. Transfer the cooked filets to a clean plate, not the plate that held the raw steaks.
  2. Rest for at least 3 minutes before cutting.
  3. Spoon the juices from the clean resting plate over the steaks and serve.

The garlic butter is already part of the seasoning, so you do not need another heavy topping. If you want a finishing sauce, serve it alongside the filet so the browned surface remains uncovered.

High-Heat Grilling vs. Smoking Filet Mignon

Low-temperature smoking and high-heat grilling are different cooking schedules, not interchangeable settings.

This recipe uses direct grilling on hot grates. It is a practical choice when you want a straightforward steak dinner without a separate smoking stage.

Reverse-searing uses a low-temperature smoke stage followed by high-heat browning. That approach can provide more smoke exposure and can be useful for thick steaks, but it requires separate control of the smoking and searing stages.

A smoker set to 225°F will not cook a filet on the short minutes-per-side schedule used for hot grilling.

Expect this version to have wood-fired flavor rather than pronounced smoke character. Extending the grilling time after the center reaches its target is not a good way to add more smoke flavor.

Serving and Storing Filet Mignon

Filet mignon pairs well with sides that add texture and contrast to the buttery steak. Good choices include:

  • Roasted potatoes and green beans
  • Sautéed mushrooms and a crisp salad
  • Asparagus with a baked potato
  • Roasted vegetables and a whole-grain side

A mushroom sauce or fresh herb sauce can add another layer of flavor, but neither is necessary. Avoid automatically adding more salt at the table because the butter rub already seasons the meat.

Filet is best served freshly cooked. Cooking only the portions you plan to eat gives the most predictable result.

Store leftovers in a covered container and reheat them before serving.

How to Check the Results and Improve the Next Cook

Exterior browning, clear juices, or a pink center cannot establish an exact internal temperature.

If a reading seems unexpectedly high or low, check again from another angle with the sensing tip in the center. A shallow reading and a center reading measure different parts of the steak.

Use the finished steak to identify what to adjust next time.

What You Notice Likely Cause What to Change
The center reached its target, but the outside is pale Surface moisture or insufficiently heated grates Dry the meat thoroughly and complete the lid-closed preheat
The outside has patches of dark, bitter garlic Garlic or butter collected in thick clumps Mince the garlic finely and spread the coating evenly
The probe reading changes sharply when repositioned The sensing tip was not consistently in the center Insert from the side and verify the thickest part
The steak is firmer and drier than intended It cooked beyond the desired endpoint Begin checking earlier and remove each filet independently

A pale crust is disappointing, but it is not a reason to keep cooking a filet whose center has already reached its target. Correct the drying or preheating on the next cook rather than sacrificing the interior to chase more color.

Have your sides and serving plates ready before the steaks finish, so the filets can come off the grill promptly, rest, and go straight to the table.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I Make This Recipe on a Traeger Redland 650?

Yes, use the recipe’s cooking method and a center-temperature reading to judge doneness. Use 450°F and a 15-minute lid-closed preheat for Traeger’s U.S. filet mignon recipe, then judge the finish with a center-temperature reading rather than the grill model or elapsed time.

Can I Use Hickory Instead of Steak Blend Pellets?

Yes, you can use a different wood pellet flavor, but the recipe specifies Steak Blend. Hickory gives you an alternative wood flavor without changing the need to control the steak’s internal temperature.

Can I Cook Filet Mignon From Frozen?

Yes, filet mignon can be grilled from frozen, but a frozen center makes a time-only approach especially unreliable. For this garlic-butter recipe, thaw the steaks in the refrigerator first for a more predictable cook; do not thaw them on the counter.